“Grottoes United Methodist Church got its start at a tabernacle built by Methodists at the cave in Shendun, (now Grottoes), in 1876. J.K. Gilbert held a six week revival, which was the actual beginning of Grottoes United Methodist Church. Sunday School was organized on May 15th, 1892 with twenty-seven scholars. Several buildings were used as meeting places until 1898 when the present church was built and dedicated under the ministry of J. Harry Smith. The church was part of the Port Republic Charge which included several churches. A parsonage was built at Port Republic in 1906. class rooms were added to our original church building in the early 1900’s. The basement was cemented and finished in 1940—adding a kitchen and fellowship hall.
In 1954 the Grottoes church became a station church. A house on Park Avenue in Grottoes was given to the church by John Eutsler to be used as a parsonage. Rev. Robert L. Tressler was appointed minister of this new station church and under his leadership an educational building was constructed on the back of the church. This added seven classrooms, a social hall, a new kitchen, two storage rooms, two restrooms and a pastor’s study. This completed the church as it stands today. Improvements such as new pews, new carpeting, new roof, new paint, new organ, new furnaces and air conditioning have been added as needed. In 2002 an old house and land next to the church was purchased with plans for additional parking . In 2010, the house was torn down and a paved parking lot installed.
Since the church began it has had several denominational names. It started as Grottoes Methodist Episcopal Church, the Grottoes Methodist Episcopal Church South, and Grottoes Methodist Church. When our denomination united with the Evangelical United Brethren Church in 1968 we became the Grottoes United Methodist Church which is the name we go by today. We have been a part of the Harrisonburg District since June of 1972.” (Taken from the Homecoming Celebration Program of October 2007)